Is the Revolver dead?

By  | December 12, 2017 | Filed under: News

Is the Revolver dead?  Has this iconic piece of self-defense machinery gone the way of the DoDo Bird?   I don’t think so.  I think that it still has a place in today’s society as a valuable tool in the Self-Defense tool box.  Okay, what started this topic?  You guessed it, two men.

I was recently talking to a buddy of mine and this question came up.  His opinion was yes, the revolver was obsolete.  Being the scientist that I am (really I will argue with a stop sign), I began to think about this question.    I took it one step forward and told him, “If you’re going to throw that question at me, let’s go further.  What is better to have in a fight for your life, eight rounds of .357 Magnum or eight rounds of .45ACP?”  I asked this question because he carries a Kimber 1911 in .45ACP.

I have recently been looking at a Smith & Wesson R-8 .357 Revolver, thinking about purchasing one.  So, I had the specs in my head.  I think this will be a good comparison.  As far as cost, the Smith & Wesson and my buddies’ Kimber were close in cost.  Below are the overall specs of the two pistols:

S&W R-8 .357                                                  Kimber TLE/RII .45ACP

  • Weight: 35.9 oz                                                            39 oz
  • Caliber: .357 Magnum, .38 Special                                 .45ACP
  • Capacity: 8 Rounds                                                      7+1 Rounds
  • Barrel Length:  5 inches                                              5 inches


Kimber TLE/RII .45ACP

Smith & Wesson R-8 .357 Magnum, 8 shot.


   Ok, let’s get to the argument, I mean discussion.  Below are his statements, followed by my answers:

-My Kimber holds 8 rounds of .45acp.

The Smith & Wesson hold 8 rounds of .357 Magnum. 

-Kimber uses a magazine that is faster to reload.

The Smith & Wesson uses a Full Moon Clip that holds the 8 rounds together.  It is basically a speed loader that stays in the gun.  Open the cylinder and place the Full Moon Clip complete with ammo in the Chambers.  Close cylinder. 

Smith & Wesson Full Moon Clip

-The Kimber is easier to carry.

I will give him that the Kimber is flatter than the Smith.  However, the Smith actually weighs less than the Kimber. 

-I can put a light on my Kimber to help with target identification.

Hmm, so can I. 

-The Kimber can be shot faster.

Go to Youtube and check out videos of Jerry Miculek.  He is one of the world’s fastest revolver shooters. 



-The revolver does not have a place in today’s Law Enforcement.

Really, let’s look at that theory.  The Smith that we are using for comparison was designed by a request from a Police Department that wanted them for their SWAT Officers that were utilizing a Ballistic Shield.  It seemed that the Officers with the Shields were experiencing malfunctions from their Semi-Auto pistols due to getting the slide to close to the shield during firing.  Don’t have that problem with the revolver. 

Smith & Wesson R-8 .357, 8 shot revolver.  **Pic taken with remote camera*


Smith & Wesson R-8 .357, 8 shot revolver.  **Pic taken with remote camera*

  • The Kimber utilizes the .45ACP Cartridge which is a proven “man stopper.”

Before I get into the answer of this, please be aware that there is no such thing as a “Magic Bullet” or “Man Stopper”.  Let’s look at facts.  Back in 1990s, Evan Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow began research and published 3 volumes of research about “One Shot Stop Percentages.”  This information was taken from actual police reports.  The information was broken down in caliber.  I happen to have the 3 books.  I checked them. 

The .357 Magnum posts a proven factor of 96 % of one shot stops.

The .45ACP posts a proven factor of 94% of one shot stops. 

Now, please remember these factors come from actual police reports.  Just as a comparison, I am including a couple of more.  Calibers that you think would have a high “One Shot Stop” sometimes doesn’t.

.44 Magnum posts a proven factor of 90% of one shot stops

.22 Long Rifle posts a proven factor of 34% of one shot stops

.380ACP posts a proven factor of 70% of one shot stops

.9mm posts a proven factor of 91% of one shot stops

Now with all the information above, who won the argument, I mean discussion?  No one, we are men; of course we are not going to admit that we were wrong.  With that being said, both sides had good points and both sides countered these points.  If a semi auto pistol is your choice, as long as you can operate it, use it.  However, some people do not have the hand strength to operate a semi-auto pistol and a revolver may be what they need.



Actually, here is the real basis to this article.  I have been a semi-auto pistol shooter forever.  I have never carried a revolver in my 21 years as a police officer.  However, yesterday, I went shooting and realized that I do not have the dexterity in my hands anymore for operation of the semi-auto pistol.  I figure this is due to the Stroke that I have had.  So now I make the change over a revolver.  It is going to be different.  Whatever your choice of a self-defense firearm, make sure you practice with it and stay proficient.    I hope this article has helped you.


Kimber TLE/RII .45ACP.  **Pic taken with Remote Camera***

Bobby Inman is retired from Law Enforcement after 21 years of Service.  He is the Store Manager of Southern Heritage Gun & Pawn in Tuscumbia.   He has articles published in Law & Order Magazine, Police Marksman Magazine, Guns & Weapons for Law Enforcement Magazine as well as several published ebooks on Amazon, Kobo Writing, as well as Nook (Barnes & Noble).  He is owner of Poopiedog, an Animal Rescue Dachshund, who is his constant companion.   He is a Senior Investigative Reporter for the Quad Cities Daily


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Johnny Mack Morrow Chad Young Frank Williamson Kyle Brown Skip The Drive Singing River Dentistry Rebecca Hovater State Farm Service One Dynamic Staffing
306 Barbecue Champy's OTR Ichiban
Southern Heritage Gun & Pawn

The Quad-Cities Daily